UGC Draft Guidelines: Teachers' bodies oppose "de-reservation" clauses
Vikas Kumar Pandit | January 28, 2024 | 09:03 PM IST | 2 mins read
The draft, published on the UGC website, outlines two key "de-reservation" clauses in Chapter 10.
NEW DELHI: The Aam Aadmi Party (AAP) teachers’ body, AADTA, has opposed the University Grants Commission's (UGC) draft guidelines on implementing reservation policies in Higher Education Institutions (HEIs). Aditya Narayan Misra, former president of the Delhi University Teachers Association (DUTA), also called for removal of the de-reservation provisions mentioned in some clauses in Chapter 10 of the proposed draft.
According to activists, the UGC proposal is a direct attack on the constitutional principles of affirmative action and social justice. They argue that reservation policies aim to address historical discrimination and ensure equitable representation for marginalised communities in public institutions, including universities and colleges.
“The de-reservation provision will open a window of discrimination against reserved category candidates. It will be shown that the institution could not find suitable candidates against reserved vacancies; hence the said posts should be de-reserved in public interest,” the AADTA press release read.
Proposed "de-reservation" clauses
The draft, published on the UGC website, outlines two key "de-reservation" clauses in Chapter 10 (10.1, 10.2). These clauses would permit unfilled reserved seats to be opened up for general category if suitable candidates from the reserved categories were not found.
Clause 10.3 permits de-reservation in case of promotion i.e. if sufficient numbers of SC/ST candidates fit for promotion against reserved vacancies are not available.
Academics and activists are opposing provisions allowing for "de-reservation" of seats reserved for historically marginalised Scheduled Castes (SCs), Scheduled Tribes (STs), and Other Backward Classes (OBCs).
“The provision of de-reservation in case of promotion will make the already dismal condition of representation in HEIs even worse. It is against enabling provisions of the Constitution which give access to justice and equal representation to the people belonging to the deprived and marginalised sections,” said Aditya Narayan Misra.
Also read UGC should uphold the principles of reservations: SFI
“We register our sharp dissent and submit that the provision of de-reservation (as outlined in Clause 10.1, 10.2 & 10.3 of Chapter 10) proposed with the final draft of guidelines for implementation of the reservation policy of the government of India in HEIs must be summarily deleted,” he adds.
Misra said that instead of de-reservation, the UGC should focus on addressing the root causes of low representation from reserved categories. They suggest implementing stronger safeguards against discrimination, improving recruitment processes, and actively nurturing talent from marginalised communities within academia.
Misra also suggested keeping the vacant reserved posts as backlog and suggests that these post must be filled with only reserved category candidates in successive advertisement for recruitment. There should be no bar on time and the number of repeated advertisements, he added.
Follow us for the latest education news on colleges and universities, admission, courses, exams, research, education policies, study abroad and more..
To get in touch, write to us at news@careers360.com.
Next Story
]Featured News
]- Karnataka's draft teacher transfer rules propose compulsory 9-year tenures in KPS, other flagship schools
- UGC helpline for reporting sexual harassment defunct from the start but listed on Saksham portal
- CAT 2026: In a first, IIM Indore to use AI-based face recognition along with admit card check at exam centres
- NCAHP Draft: ‘Unqualified’ allied health science professionals need bridge course, exam to keep practising
- Small-town students lack awareness, not merit; institutions must help them with scholarships, admissions
- MANUU BVoc, MVoc: What’s the NCAHP registration row and why are 600 allied health science students protesting?
- AIIMS Delhi, JIPMER, others: 1 in 7 resident doctors at top medical colleges quit midway; UDF urges probe
- Over 2,500 reserved faculty posts vacant across 17 IITs; at 10 institutes, over 60 depts with no SC teacher
- Share teachers before school closure; mergers, student relocation must be last resort: EAC PM paper
- ‘Not a course assignment…’: MS student turns off-syllabus research into Elsevier paper; this is how