Education must be left to educationists, says SC
Press Trust of India | October 13, 2020 | 10:05 AM IST | 2 mins read
NEW DELHI :“Education must be left to educationists”, the Supreme Court said on Monday while setting aside an Allahabad High Court's 2018 verdict which had held that an M. Ed. qualified person could not be appointed as an Assistant Professor for the subject of Education.
The controversy centered around the sole issue of whether an M.Ed. Degree can be treated as an equivalent degree to M.A. (Education) for the purposes of appointment to the post of Assistant Professor as published in March, 2014 by the Uttar Pradesh Higher Education Service Selection Commission (UPHESSC).
The UPHESSC took help of an expert panel of four educationists who opined that for the post of Assistant Professor (Teaching), Faculty of Arts, the degree of M.Ed., as well as, the qualification of M.A. (Education) should be accepted. Based on the opinion, the employing authority UPHESSC came out with a corrigendum on July 11, 2016 and allowed candidates having the two degrees to compete for the posts.
However, a division Bench of the Allahabad High Court, on May 14, 2018, opined that while M A (Education) is a master's degree in the subject concerned, M.Ed. is not so, as it is only a training qualification.
“The conclusion reached was that an M.Ed. qualified person could not be appointed to the post of Assistant Professor in Education, and consequently the corrigendum dated July 11, 2016 was quashed,” the High Court had held. A bench of justices S K Kaul, Aniruddha Bose and Krishna Murari found fault with the high court's verdict and set it aside by allowing the appeal of one candidate Anand Yadav.
“We say so in view of the fact that matters of education must be left to educationists, of course subject to being governed by the relevant statutes and regulations. It is not the function of this Court to sit as an expert body over the decision of the experts, especially when the experts are all eminent people as apparent from the names as set out…,” the bench said.
“We are, thus, of the view that the impugned judgment is not sustainable and has to be set aside, and the challenge to the corrigendum dated July 11, is repelled.
The result having already been computed and awaiting declaration should now be declared forthwith so that persons looking for employment, as per the requisite eligibility criteria, can be employed, and so that the students have the benefit of education from the persons so employed,” it said.
Also read:
- Delhi University starts its first fully online admission process
- NTA confirms NEET 2020 exam phase 2
Write to us at news@careers360.com .
Follow us for the latest education news on colleges and universities, admission, courses, exams, research, education policies, study abroad and more..
To get in touch, write to us at news@careers360.com.
Quick Watch
]Featured News
]- Odisha SSB lecturers protest for UGC pay scale, ‘assistant prof’ tag; exam for 786 posts stalled for 2 years
- Karnataka's draft teacher transfer rules propose compulsory 9-year tenures in KPS, other flagship schools
- UGC helpline for reporting sexual harassment defunct from the start but listed on Saksham portal
- CAT 2026: In a first, IIM Indore to use AI-based face recognition along with admit card check at exam centres
- NCAHP Draft: ‘Unqualified’ allied health science professionals need bridge course, exam to keep practising
- Small-town students lack awareness, not merit; institutions must help them with scholarships, admissions
- MANUU BVoc, MVoc: What’s the NCAHP registration row and why are 600 allied health science students protesting?
- AIIMS Delhi, JIPMER, others: 1 in 7 resident doctors at top medical colleges quit midway; UDF urges probe
- Over 2,500 reserved faculty posts vacant across 17 IITs; at 10 institutes, over 60 depts with no SC teacher
- Share teachers before school closure; mergers, student relocation must be last resort: EAC PM paper