NIRF revamps ranking system; to introduce negative marking for retraction of research papers: Report
Suviral Shukla | July 19, 2025 | 01:37 PM IST | 1 min read
A formula has been developed to assign negative weightage based on either the number or percentage of retractions, the report added.
In a major revamp, the National Institutional Ranking Framework (NIRF) has announced to award negative marking for the retraction of research papers by journals, as reported by Telegram India.
A formula has been developed to assign negative weightage based on either the number or percentage of retractions, the report added.
Currently, NIRF awards weightage to institutions based on several parameters under teaching-learning and resources (TLR) such as research and professional practice (RP), which includes publications, intellectual property rights, and patents; graduation outcomes (GO), including metric university examination results and PhDs awarded, among others.
In June, V Ramgopal Rao, the vice-chancellor of Birla Institute of Technology and Science, Pilani (BITS) remarked: “The NIRF should integrate negative weightage to retracted papers and papers published in journals which get delisted from the international databases like Web of Science and Scopus.”
Also read UGC suggests parameters for selecting peer-reviewed journals after scrapping UGC-CARE list
Institutional reactions on NIRF’s negative marking move
“Sadly, in the last two years, the number of retractions of papers has been increasing. We have got complaints about this from various quarters. Retraction will be a factor for negative weightage in this year’s NIRF,” said Anil Sahashrabudhe, chairman of the National Board of Accreditation (NBA), the agency managing the NIRF.
Sahashrabudhe also emphasized the role of internal quality assurance cells and research deans, stating that they must remain vigilant and take disciplinary action against faculty members responsible for repeated paper retractions.
He further noted that the penalty for retractions will be more significant in the future. “This year, there is a minor penalty with negative marking,” Sahashrabudhe added.
Anindya Sen, former professor of IIM Calcutta, also shared her views, stating that applying negative weightage for retracted papers poses challenges.
“The NIRF, being an annual exercise, would see the retracted papers of the previous academic year. The papers retracted after two or three years would escape the NIRF’s assessment,” she added.
Follow us for the latest education news on colleges and universities, admission, courses, exams, research, education policies, study abroad and more..
To get in touch, write to us at news@careers360.com.
Quick Watch
]Next Story
]Featured News
]- MUHS Nashik physiotherapy colleges find NCAHP’s land, staffing, seat norms ‘practically impossible’ to meet
- Odisha SSB lecturers protest for UGC pay scale, ‘assistant prof’ tag; exam for 786 posts stalled for 2 years
- Karnataka's draft teacher transfer rules propose compulsory 9-year tenures in KPS, other flagship schools
- UGC helpline for reporting sexual harassment defunct from the start but listed on Saksham portal
- CAT 2026: In a first, IIM Indore to use AI-based face recognition along with admit card check at exam centres
- NCAHP Draft: ‘Unqualified’ allied health science professionals need bridge course, exam to keep practising
- Small-town students lack awareness, not merit; institutions must help them with scholarships, admissions
- MANUU BVoc, MVoc: What’s the NCAHP registration row and why are 600 allied health science students protesting?
- AIIMS Delhi, JIPMER, others: 1 in 7 resident doctors at top medical colleges quit midway; UDF urges probe
- Over 2,500 reserved faculty posts vacant across 17 IITs; at 10 institutes, over 60 depts with no SC teacher