Bombay HC allows amendment to NEET UG 2025 petition challenging CAP seat upgrade rule
Vikas Kumar Pandit | November 17, 2025 | 01:46 PM IST | 2 mins read
Maharashtra NEET UG 2025 Counselling: Candidates who secured CAP round 3 seats remain barred from upgrading to newly vacated seats. Lower-scoring students are able to claim these seats, prompting a legal challenge against the rule in the Bombay High Court.
Download the NEET Most Scoring Chapters and Topics PDF based on the past 5 years’ analysis. Focus on high-weightage topics and boost your NEET preparation.
Download EBookThe Bombay High Court has granted permission to a petitioner to amend a writ petition concerning the admissions process for Health Science courses under the National Eligibility cum Entrance Test Undergraduates (NEET UG) 2025 in Maharashtra. The petition, filed by Purva Milind Wagh against the State of Maharashtra and others, raises issues regarding Clause 11.2.9.1 of the Common Admission Process (CAP) Information Brochure.
During the hearing, the bench comprising Justices Ravindra V Ghuge and Ashwin D Bhobe considered submissions from the petitioner and the SCET Cell. The petitioner argued that Clause 11.2.9.1 prohibits candidates who secured admission in CAP round 3 from participating in the CAP stray vacancy round.
“Clause 11.2.9.1 specifies a prohibition on candidates who have secured admission in CAP Round 3, from participating in the online CAP Stray Vacancy Rounds, for the available seats,” the official petition said.
NEET UG Counselling 2025: Policy disadvantages meritorious students
The issue arises from candidates who initially secured admission in top-ranking colleges for courses like BAMS, BUMS, BHMS, BNYS, BPTh, BOTh, BASLP, and BP&O, but later obtained MBBS seats. When these candidates vacated their earlier seats, candidates with higher marks, including the petitioner, could not upgrade to the newly available seats due to the prohibition. Meanwhile, candidates with lower scores were able to secure the vacated seats.
The petitioner argued that this policy disadvantages meritorious students by forcing them to remain in seats with high fees while others with lower scores gain access to better seats.
Also read Tamil Nadu seeks SC intervention on bill to replace NEET with Class 12 marks
Petitioner challenges Maharashtra CAP disqualification clause
The petitioner sought to challenge the disqualification clause under Clause 11.2.9.1, along with other provisions of the Information Brochure and Notice No. 22 dated October 17, 2025. The court observed that the petitioner has a strong arguable case and granted leave to amend the petition.
The court’s order states, “Having noticed that the Petitioner has a strong arguable case against the disqualification clause under Clause 11.2.9.1, we permit the Petitioner to prepare the additional pleadings, grounds, and prayer clauses for amending the Petition,” granting the petitioner leave to amend the petition and challenge the rule barring seat upgrades.
The issue of seat upgradation has also been highlighted in the ongoing Maharashtra NEET UG 2025 stray vacancy round , where 484 MBBS and BDS seats are vacant and the choice filling facility is open till November 13.
Medical education counsellor Sudha Shenoy criticised the State CET Cell for delaying the addition of NMC-approved seats, calling it a “gross injustice” to students who had already joined CAP round 3 seats. High-scoring students remain barred from upgrading even to these newly added seats, while lower-scoring candidates may access them, reflecting the practical effect of the rule now being challenged in the High Court petition.
Follow us for the latest education news on colleges and universities, admission, courses, exams, research, education policies, study abroad and more..
To get in touch, write to us at news@careers360.com.
Quick Watch
]Next Story
]Featured News
]- Karnataka's draft teacher transfer rules propose compulsory 9-year tenures in KPS, other flagship schools
- UGC helpline for reporting sexual harassment defunct from the start but listed on Saksham portal
- CAT 2026: In a first, IIM Indore to use AI-based face recognition along with admit card check at exam centres
- NCAHP Draft: ‘Unqualified’ allied health science professionals need bridge course, exam to keep practising
- Small-town students lack awareness, not merit; institutions must help them with scholarships, admissions
- MANUU BVoc, MVoc: What’s the NCAHP registration row and why are 600 allied health science students protesting?
- AIIMS Delhi, JIPMER, others: 1 in 7 resident doctors at top medical colleges quit midway; UDF urges probe
- Over 2,500 reserved faculty posts vacant across 17 IITs; at 10 institutes, over 60 depts with no SC teacher
- Share teachers before school closure; mergers, student relocation must be last resort: EAC PM paper
- ‘Not a course assignment…’: MS student turns off-syllabus research into Elsevier paper; this is how