NMC’s revised CBME guidelines failed to honour rights of disabled, transgender persons: Doctors
CBME Guidelines for MBBS Curriculum: Doctor groups write to the social justice minister demanding provisions of rights of disabled and transgender persons.
Vagisha Kaushik | September 13, 2024 | 12:46 PM IST
NEW DELHI : Expressing disappointment over the revised NMC CBME guidelines, the disability and transgender groups are demanding the restoration of the provisions under the Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act, 2016 and the Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, 2019 in the new MBBS curriculum. The National Medical Commission (NMC) re-released the Competency Based Medical Education (CBME) guidelines, dropping references to sodomy and lesbianism as “unnatural” after receiving backlash on the previous document.
In a letter to the Union minister of social justice and empowerment, the doctors belonging to the disabled and transgender communities sought his intervention and demanded re-introduction of mandatory hours on disability competencies before the commencement of new MBBS session; and integration of RPDA and TPA into the AETCOM (Attitude, Ethics, and Communication) curriculum with case studies in the context of disability, transgender, intersex, and queer persons. They also sought involvement of health professionals and students from the disability and queer community for such revisions, and sensitization of members of NMC and its medical boards on the two Acts.
Issues with NMC guidelines on MBBS curriculum
The health professionals believe that the revised CBME guidelines failed to honour the Acts despite NMC’s acknowledgement of its mistake in the media. They argued that there is no mention of the major terms such as “dignity” and “transgender” in the 466-page document. In the curriculum, during the two-week foundation course, eight hours of protected time is dedicated to “sports”, however, there is no explicit mention of disability competencies which were mandatory in the 2019 curriculum being seven hours, they pointed out.
“Psychiatry continues to refer to “gender identity disorders” and Physiology describe sexual differentiation/intersex variations as “abnormalities.” Furthermore, Pediatrics fails to address gender incongruence, dysphoria, or non-heterosexual orientations not mentioning SOGIESC,” the letter read as the groups pointed out the deficiencies in the latest CBME curriculum .
Provisions of RPDA, TPA
The medical groups recalled that not only did the United Nations (UN) India praise the inclusion of the disability competencies, the National Council on Disability in the United States (US) took inspiration from the practice. Even the World Health Organization (WHO)’s guidelines also mandated the training for all healthcare professionals.
The doctors reminded the public how the Acts mandate inclusion of the rights of these communities in the educational institutions which the medical commission has disregarded. “Section 39 (2)(f) of the RPDA mandates the inclusion of the rights of persons with disabilities in the curriculum of universities, colleges, and schools. Section 47 (1)(b) further requires the integration of disability as a component in all educational courses for university teachers, doctors, nurses, and paramedical personnel. This is a mandatory requirement, which the NMC has blatantly disregarded,” they said.
Also read Why NMC derecognised CPS Mumbai courses and then restored recognition
They further complained that the new guidelines are only focussed on the typical male and female binary and disregard transgender people. “As per section 15 of the TPA 2019: 15. The appropriate Government shall take the following measures in relation to transgender persons, namely: (e) review of medical curriculum and research for doctors to address their specific health issues; (d) bring out a Health Manual related to sex reassignment surgery in accordance with the World Profession Association for Transgender Health guidelines,” the letter quoted.
Further, the healthcare professionals alleged that they didn’t receive any response from the health minister despite writing to him twice.
Follow us for the latest education news on colleges and universities, admission, courses, exams, research, education policies, study abroad and more..
To get in touch, write to us at news@careers360.com.
Next Story
]‘Alarmingly high’: 28% MBBS students have mental disorders; over 60% face financial stress, finds NMC
The National Medical Commission’s survey found that over 56% PG students don’t get weekly offs; 65% MBBS students have wanted to quit and over 50% teachers think students use mental stress is ‘an excuse’
SanjayFeatured News
]- Kanpur: A year after Yogi Adityanath’s school mergers, many pushed out of mainstream education
- CBSE-transition deferred based on feedback, mass failure in test: Andhra Pradesh Government
- Mothers cook, doctors are male: Southern textbooks more sexist than NCERT, ‘Hindi-belt’ ones, says study
- No full-time Delhi DoE director since last year, educational reforms, teachers’ transfers stalled
- NMC revises CBME guidelines for MBBS curriculum; drops reference to gay sex as ‘unnatural’
- AIIMS Gorakhpur Controversy: Head of surgery accuses executive director of forging son’s OBC certificate
- IIT Guwahati student death: Dean resigns; admin allows failed students to join placements, internships
- 75% attendance rule, backlogs reasons for IIT Guwahati student death, classmates call out instructor
- NLU Delhi scraps mid-semester exams after student’s suicide on campus
- Why NMC derecognised CPS Mumbai courses and then restored recognition